Hayden Insurance Agency
Auto · Home · Life · Business

The people behind your policy, not just the paperwork.

Hayden Insurance Agency provides coverage for families and business owners who would rather have a conversation with a person they know and trust rather than a revolving door of call center representatives.

Request a quote Call (508) 209-1871 Facebook

Call or email us directly — most quote requests get a reply within one business day.

What clients say

Real reviews from real clients, straight from our Facebook and Google pages.

96%
recommend us on Google and Facebook
Read our Google reviews Read our Facebook reviews

We'd rather show you genuine reviews than invent quotes — tap through to read them in clients' own words on Facebook and Google.

Our mission

At Hayden Insurance Agency, protecting your family is our number one priority. We're here to bring a personal touch back to insurance in today's world full of AI. With growing insurance needs for today and tomorrow's concerns, let us show you what makes us different from other insurance agencies. At Hayden Insurance Agency, your family is our family.

Our story

With 20+ personal years in the insurance field, we are confident that we will be able to provide you with the knowledge and experience you would expect from a professional and time tested insurance agency. Massachusetts is our home. It's where we grew up, it's where we went to school, and it's where we plan to run our business for the rest of our lives. We are proud to offer such great companies and products to an area that deserves nothing but the best.

We are your servicing local agency specializing in Plymouth, Carver, Pembroke, Hanover, Middleborough, Bridgewater, Wareham, Sandwich, Bourne, Falmouth, Hyannis, and everywhere else on The South Shore and Cape Cod!

All kinds of coverage, one point of contact

You don't need four different agents for four different risks. Hayden Insurance Agency handles all of it, so your policies actually talk to each other.

Home Insurance

Your home is where the paperwork should stop mattering. We cover the structure, what's inside it, and the liability that comes with owning it.

  • Dwelling & personal property
  • Liability protection
  • Water, wind & storm damage
  • Discounts for bundling with auto

Auto Insurance

From a daily commuter to a family fleet, we build a policy around how you actually drive, not a generic rate card.

  • Liability & collision
  • Comprehensive coverage
  • Multi-vehicle discounts
  • Roadside assistance options

Life Insurance

A plan for the people who depend on you. We'll walk through term and permanent options in plain language, no pressure.

  • Term life
  • Whole & universal life
  • Coverage that grows with your family
  • No-medical-exam options available

Business Insurance

For the local shops, contractors, and small businesses that keep this area running. Coverage sized to how you actually operate.

  • General liability
  • Property & equipment
  • Workers' compensation
  • Business interruption coverage

One agent, every policy

Home, auto, life, and business coverage under a single point of contact — no re-explaining your situation to a different department each time.

Independent & local

We're not locked into one insurer, so we shop multiple carriers to find the coverage and price that actually fits your household or business.

A real person on claims day

When something goes wrong, you call an agent — not a queue. We help you through the claims process from the first call to the payout.

Request a quote

Tell us a bit about yourself and what you'd like covered. We'll follow up by phone or email to fill in the rest.

We'll call you at this time for a 30-minute policy review — completing the form also adds it to your own calendar.

Submitting sends these details straight to Hayden Insurance Agency, downloads a calendar invite for your call, and opens our secure carrier upload page in a new tab so you can share your current coverage pages directly.

Frequently asked questions

Still curious about something? Call or email us directly and we'll answer it before your quote call.

How do I get a quote?

Fill out the quote request form on this page, call (508) 209-1871, or email Matthew@HaydenAgency.com with the type of coverage you're after and a little about your situation — property, vehicle, family, or business. Most requests get a reply within one business day, followed by a short call to fill in the details.

Can I bundle my home and auto insurance?

Yes. Bundling home and auto is one of the most common ways clients lower their overall premium, and it means one renewal date and one agent for both policies.

What's the difference between term and whole life insurance?

Term life covers you for a set period — often 10 to 30 years — at a lower cost. Whole and universal life last your entire life and build cash value over time. We'll help you weigh the two against your budget and what you're actually trying to protect.

Do you work with businesses as well as individuals?

Yes — business clients are a core part of the agency, from single-location shops to contractors and multi-vehicle operations. We can write general liability, property, workers' comp, and business interruption coverage.

How do I file a claim?

Call or email us as soon as you can after an incident. We'll help you open the claim with the right carrier and stay in the loop with you through the process, rather than leaving you to deal with it alone.

Will requesting a quote affect my current policy?

No. Requesting a quote is just a conversation — nothing changes with your existing coverage unless and until you decide to switch.

Ready to see what better coverage costs?

Send us a note with what you're looking to cover — home, auto, life, or your business — and get a straight answer back.

Request a quote (508) 209-1871